No big surprise that Gandalf would have Radagast's staff, since it is the same staff that he (Gandalf, obviously, since Radagast isn't there) has in FOTR. But is it confirmation that Radagast will be killed? One piece of contrary evidence is what John Howe said in the EE appendices. He says that by the time of LOTR, Radagast forgets his mission, forgets that he is an Istari, and becomes like a Shaman or nature spirit in the forest. That suggests to me that he does not die, but rather passes his staff to Gandalf (perhaps because Gandalf's staff is broken, maybe by the Witchking!) because the Grey Wizard has a greater need of it, and Radagast then passes out of the story, explaining his absence in LOTR. Howe's comments are true to what Tolkien wrote, as quoted in UT ("For Radagast, the fourth, became enamoured of the many beasts and birds that dwelt in Middle-earth, and forsook Elves and Men, and spent his days among wild creatures"), other than that the timing is wrong. Radagast obviously is still aware of his mission in LOTR in the books. So the question is, was Howe discussing Radagast as written by Tolkien, and just misstating as to the timing, was he (as PtB has suggested) just talking about their conception for Radagast, or was he revealing Radagast's ultimate film-fate?Elsewhere, Passdagas the Brown wrote:That was hilarious! I love PJ pushing his AD out of the way, and the photo of PJ on McCoy's phone, holding his Oscar. And yes, McKellen seems to be holding Radagast's staff in a ruined Dale...Elentári wrote:Did you guys also get this?
The Five-ish Doctors Reboot
Watch out (if it's not restricted to UK viewers only) for a cameo by Gandalf and SPJ on the Dale set around the 13 minute mark...
Does he (gasp) have Radagast's staff??
I am about 93% certain that Radagast will kick the bucket. Either at the close of DoS, or in TABA.
I am betting on the latter.